Welcome to I Made Extra, a registered and insured microbakery based in Atlanta, GA that focuses on familiar favorites done right!
Each item is made with precision and intention— letting quality ingredients and technique speak for themselves. The result is baked goods worth sharing! (Or hiding in your nightstand so you can have them all to yourself. We wont judge.)
I Made Extra
Extra, where it counts
Why Choose I Made EXTRA?
We offer a range of services to meet the needs of every client. Have something else in mind? We'd be happy to work with you to create a custom quote.
-
Our core menu is built on baked goods people already know and love; we just make ‘em better!
By refining ratios and deepening flavors, we take what’s familiar and elevated it without losing what made it special in the first place.
We believe classic doesn’t necessarily mean boring or run of the mill. So we do all the fan favorites, just perfected!
-
At I Made Extra, we believe that good food and mass production are incompatible.
We proudly choose the right side of that equation, handcrafting each baked good in small batches with high-quality ingredients.
Each batch reflects our awareness that dialing in on the finer details can transform the ordinary into something rather magical.
We may not make a lot, but what we do make, we make incredibly well.
-
We believe in pushing boundaries for most things, but baked goods are where we draw the line.
The “TIktokificaton” of desserts has fundamentally changed the baked good game. Now, everything is overloaded with toppings and mix-ins that distract from what actually matters – strong technique that facilitates perfect flavor, texture and balance.
For us, extra isn’t about more. It’s about maximizing what simple, high-quality ingredients have to offer.
Our Commitment to Quality
Organic, Unbleached & Unenriched Flour
The foundation matters. We use flour without bleaching agents or unnecessary additives for a cleaner taste.
High-Quality Chocolate (Never Chips)
We use chopped chocolate bars and premium cocoa—not standard chips—for a smoother melt and textural variety.
Real Dairy, Always
Only real butter and cream—never substitutes. From browned butter to sweet and salty caramels, dairy is where richness and depth begin.
Pure Extracts & Whole Ingredients
No artificial flavors. Just real vanilla extract, whole eggs, and ingredients you can recognize with names you can actually pronounce.